Good day sir. I made the attempt to trace the formula in your link, $A = R(a + b - c)$, but with no success. I notice however that at the bottom there is this line, $R = (a + b - c)/2$.
The radius of inscribed circle however is given by $R = (a + b + c)/2$ and this is true for any triangle, may it right or not. I have this derivation of radius of incircle here: https://www.mathalino.com/node/581.
I think that is the reason why that formula for area don't add up.
Thank you for reviewing my post. I think, if you'll look again, you'll find my formula for the area of a right triangle is A = R (a + b - R), not A = R (a+ b - c).
Also, by your formula, R = (a + b + c) / 2 would mean that R for a 3, 4, 5 triangle would be 6.00, whereas, mine R = (a + b - c) /2 gives a R of 1.00.
My bad sir, I was not so keen in reading your post, even my own formula for R is actually wrong here. It should be $R = A_t / s$, not $R = (a + b + c)/2$ because $(a + b + c)/2 = s$ in the link I provided.
Anyway, thank again for the link to Dr. Math page. I never look at the triangle like that, the reason I was not able to arrive to your formula. Though simpler, it is more clever. I will add to this post the derivation of your formula based on the figure of Dr. Math. Thanks.
Forum posts (unless otherwise specified) licensed under a Creative Commons Licence. All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective owners. Forum posts are owned by the individual posters.
Good day sir. I made the
Good day sir. I made the attempt to trace the formula in your link, $A = R(a + b - c)$, but with no success. I notice however that at the bottom there is this line, $R = (a + b - c)/2$.
The radius of inscribed circle however is given by $R = (a + b + c)/2$ and this is true for any triangle, may it right or not. I have this derivation of radius of incircle here: https://www.mathalino.com/node/581.
I think that is the reason why that formula for area don't add up.
Thank you for reviewing my
In reply to Good day sir. I made the by Jhun Vert
Thank you for reviewing my post. I think, if you'll look again, you'll find my formula for the area of a right triangle is A = R (a + b - R), not A = R (a+ b - c).
Also, by your formula, R = (a + b + c) / 2 would mean that R for a 3, 4, 5 triangle would be 6.00, whereas, mine R = (a + b - c) /2 gives a R of 1.00.
See link below for another example:
http://mathforum.org/library/drmath/view/54670.html
My bad sir, I was not so keen
In reply to Thank you for reviewing my by BobDH
My bad sir, I was not so keen in reading your post, even my own formula for R is actually wrong here. It should be $R = A_t / s$, not $R = (a + b + c)/2$ because $(a + b + c)/2 = s$ in the link I provided.
Anyway, thank again for the link to Dr. Math page. I never look at the triangle like that, the reason I was not able to arrive to your formula. Though simpler, it is more clever. I will add to this post the derivation of your formula based on the figure of Dr. Math. Thanks.
No problem. Thanks for adding
In reply to My bad sir, I was not so keen by Jhun Vert
No problem. Thanks for adding the new derivation. Nice presentation.
For the convenience of future
For the convenience of future learners, here are the formulas from the given link:
$A = r(a + b - r)$
$r = \dfrac{a + b - c}{2}$
Derivation:
From the figure below, AD is congruent to AE and BF is congruent to BE. Hence:
Area ADO = Area AEO = A2
Area BFO = Area BEO = A3
Area of triangle ABC
$A = A_1 + 2A_2 + 2A_3$
$A = r^2 + 2\left[ \dfrac{r(b - r)}{2} \right] + 2\left[ \dfrac{r(a - r)}{2} \right]$
$A = r^2 + (br - r^2) + (ar - r^2)$
$A = br + ar - r^2$
$A = r(a + b - r)$ ← the formula
Radius of inscribed circle:
$AE + EB = AB$
$(b - r) + (a - r) = c$
$a + b - c = 2r$
$r = \dfrac{a + b - c}{2}$ ← the formula